Why your email open rate isn’t true

The email open rate – for a newsletter or an automated email alike – depends on a tiny, invisible image. When the email’s images load, the email platform records an “open”. That worked well for years. It doesn’t any more.

Since 2021, Apple’s Mail app has downloaded email images in advance, in the background, for most users. The email counts as “opened” even if the recipient never looked at it. This is Apple Mail’s privacy feature, Mail Privacy Protection.

That’s a big problem, because the vast majority of opens now come from Apple devices. According to Litmus data from October 2026, nearly 76% of tracked opens are linked to Apple devices. Gmail follows with 17%. Litmus itself says that opens behind Apple’s privacy feature can’t be considered reliable.

Open and click data in 202675.84 percent of tracked opens come from Apple devices and 17.02 percent from Gmail. According to Klaviyo, the average click rate is 1.69 percent for campaigns and 5.58 percent for automations.OPENS AND CLICKS IN 202675.84%of tracked opens from Apple devices17.02%from Gmail1.69%average click rate for campaigns5.58%average click rate for automationsSources: Litmus, October 2026 (1.7 billion opens); Klaviyo 2026 benchmarks (183,000+ customers).
Most opens come from environments where an open doesn’t mean real reading.

The result is simple: your newsletter open rate is inflated. The more of your customers use iPhones, the more it’s inflated. In an online store where most customers order from a phone – and many of them from an iPhone – the distortion can be significant.

What is a good email open rate in 2026?

According to Klaviyo’s 2026 benchmarks, based on data from more than 183,000 customers, the average open rate is 31% for campaigns and 32.2% for automations. The top 10% are above 45%.

These are global averages. Your own numbers may differ, depending on your list and your industry.

The figures are fine as general guidance. For decisions, they aren’t enough. Today, the difference in open rate between two emails often comes from which part of the list had more iPhone users – not from which subject line was better.

Stripo’s 2026 overview estimates that the reported open rate may be 10–30% higher than real reading. Treat this with caution: it’s the company’s own estimate, and it didn’t publish its method. But the direction matches every other source: an open is now a signal, not a result.

Next step: consent for open tracking

In France and Italy, from 2026, most marketing emails need the recipient’s prior consent for the tracking pixels that measure opens.

The French data protection authority (CNIL) published its recommendation on 14 April 2026, and the Italian authority (Garante) its guidance on 29 April. Existing lists had a transition period: subscribers had to be informed and given the chance to object by 14 July 2026 in France and by 28 October in Italy.

Klaviyo has already added two settings because of this. Open tracking can be switched off for the whole account, and consent can be stored per recipient. The company has promised consent collection in signup forms for later in 2026.

According to a 2026 legal analysis, the French and Italian guidance are the first comprehensive regulator guidance on the topic. But according to the European Data Protection Board (EDPB), the ePrivacy Directive also covers tracking technologies used in emails. So it’s worth building your measurement so that it works without open tracking.

Measure this instead of the open rate

Four metrics that reflect a real human decision, and that background image downloads don’t distort.

  1. Click-through rate (clicks / delivered emails). This shows how many people did something because of the email. According to Klaviyo’s 2026 data, the average is 1.69% for campaigns and 5.58% for automations. Watch the formula: some platforms divide clicks by opens, and that is just as distorted.
  2. Placed-order rate. The share of recipients who ordered after the email. For an online store, this matters most. According to Klaviyo, automations have a placed-order rate 13 times that of campaigns.
  3. Revenue per recipient. Revenue attributed to the email divided by the number of recipients. It lets you compare emails sent to lists of different sizes. According to Klaviyo, it’s almost 18 times higher for automations than for campaigns.
  4. Unsubscribes and spam complaints. These show the “health” of your list. If a campaign gets lots of clicks but many people unsubscribe, the next emails will pay for it.

A fifth number for the monthly report: email-attributed revenue as a share of the store’s total revenue. Always keep the two apart. One is the store’s total sales; the other is what the emails brought in according to the email platform. If you want to see where you stand, the email marketing audit starts with exactly this.

The hidden risk: open-based automations and segments

Inflated opens don’t just spoil the report. They also make bad decisions in the background, automatically.

  • The “engaged subscribers” segment. If the segment is built on “opened in the last 90 days”, it treats many addresses as active where nobody actually reads. You keep emailing them, which hurts deliverability.
  • “Resend to non-openers” emails. Almost all Apple users look like “openers”, so they’re left out. The resend misses exactly the addresses wrongly treated as active.
  • Subject line tests. If the winner is picked by open rate, chance often decides. Set the test to clicks or orders.
  • Automation (flow) branches. If a sequence branches on “opened the previous email?”, switch it to a click or a site visit. The same goes for sunset sequences that filter out inactive subscribers.

In the automation library you can see which sequence is built on which event. And in the article on abandoned cart and browse abandonment emails I show how I measure an automation’s real results.

What does this mean for an online store? 5 steps

  1. Change the main metric in your report. Put click-through rate, placed-order rate and revenue per recipient first, instead of open rate.
  2. Review your segments. In “active” or “engaged” segments, use clicks, site visits or orders alongside opens.
  3. Review your automations. Switch every branch that decides on opens to clicks or purchases.
  4. Set your tests to clicks. For subject line tests too, clicks or orders should decide the winner.
  5. Prepare to work without open tracking. If you have customers in France or Italy, this may already be mandatory. If not, it’s still the right direction.

If you use Klaviyo, these settings can usually be reviewed in an afternoon. The harder part is basing your decisions on different numbers from then on.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good email open rate for an online store?

According to Klaviyo’s 2026 data, the average is 31% for campaigns and 32.2% for automations. Apple’s privacy feature inflates these numbers, so use them for orientation, and judge success by click-through rate, placed-order rate and revenue per recipient instead.

What is Apple Mail Privacy Protection?

A privacy feature of Apple’s Mail app that, since 2021, downloads email images in advance in the background. Because of this, an email counts as opened even if the recipient didn’t read it.

Do I need consent to track email opens?

In France and Italy, regulators introduced such a requirement in 2026 for most marketing emails; according to a 2026 legal analysis, these are the first comprehensive regulator guidance on the topic. Based on the direction of EU rules, it’s worth building measurement that also works without open tracking. For a specific case, ask a data protection professional.

How should I measure subject line tests if not by opens?

By clicks or orders. This needs more recipients than an open-based test, but the result shows real behaviour, not the share of iPhone users.

This article is based on public sources and my own professional experience.